Reviewed by Sandra Scholes
Synopsis: William Harrow, aka the Killer Duke or Temple is accused of murdering Mara Lowe before her wedding day. He was not able to receive his rightful title. Now he works at a successful casino, but even still that one night completely destroys any good aspects of his reputation. Temple is annoyed to see Mara return to him with a proposal even though she should by rights be dead. This proposal could clear his now tarnished name, offering to come back into polite society in order to put right his reputation for good, but what does she want in return?
Review: When the rules of the ton are broken...no good duke goes unpunished, or at least that's the theory. As the third book in the Rule of Scoundrels series, the first being A Rogue by Any Other Name, and the second one One Good Earl Deserves a Lover (of which I thoroughly enjoyed) this one is a jewel among paperbacks with a cover that belies what is really inside. Of all the opening lines of a novel, this one is this years' favourite and I'm sure it will stick in the mind of other readers too. Temple fights at the aptly named Fallen Angel gambling establishment in Mayfair after losing his title, family and right to his fortune. His manager, Chase has a long list of high standing men who want to fight him, a well-known killer duke and live, or win (which they don't) but there is one man he will never face no matter what the odds, and this seems to be his Achilles heel in the story.
- Chase saying he doesn't believe he killed Mara.
- The fight scene at the beginning with Temple and Montlake - I was surprised at how lethal the blows were and how realistic.
- Temple won't fight Christopher Lowe - could it be that he is innocent of his sister's murder?
- Lavender, the MacIntyre piglet...awww.
Final Thoughts: The general plot of Temple getting revenge on Mara aside, he isn't seeing the whole picture. While he sees only having his revenge on her for what she did to him, he doesn't see her as a governess who does her best to look after the illegitimate boys at the orphanage. These boys are the love children of some of the most high standing men in London who would rather not have their illicit affairs made public. She struggles to keep the boys fed and the orphanage heated at winter, so her deal with Temple is promising to her if only to give the boys a decent life. Temple starts out by only wanting revenge and sets the ground rules for it with Mara, but when he gets too close to her, he finds he can't let her go despite how he feels about her. No Good Duke Goes Unpunished by Sarah MacLean is one of the best romance novels of 2013 and Sarah MacLean is a writer I will look out for in the future.